Maytal, joined by JSpaceCanada board members Dave Borzykowski and Esther Blum, discuss their recent visit to the Nakba Exhibit at the Canadian Museum of Human Rights in Winnipeg, their reflections, concerns, and how we should navigate these conversations.

For a downloadable, audio-only recording, click here.

Entry to exhibit
Palestinian artifacts - Keffiyah and fruit wrapping papers
Palestinian artifacts - keys from homes abandoned during the Nakba
Primo Levi poem, If This Is a Man - reminiscent of Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish's Think of Others.
Museum Exterior
Introduction to the museum
Elie Wiesel quote
Opening line of Article 1 in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Transcript:

Maytal Kowalski

Hello, Esther and Dave. How are you both doing? So, for folks that are tuning in this week, it is not Jon with me. It is two of my incredible board members on the JSpace Canada board, both based in Winnipeg, Manitoba, my hometown. Looks like you’re still the weather’s still holding out for y’all there, here in even though we’re still mid October. And the reason they’re doing this a little bit differently today, and the reason that I’ve got Esther and Dave with me, is because last month the three of us went to the Canadian Museum for Human Rights to look at the Nakba exhibit. This was obviously an exhibit that I think anyone tuning in knows faced a lot of controversy, a lot of pushback in the Jewish community, and you know, we kind of I spoke about it in one of my Substack posts and weekly emails, but at that point I hadn’t seen it and kind of made mention of the fact that I hadn’t seen it. But I did kind of feel like if we are going to talk about it, or if people around us are going to be talking about it, you know, you should we should see it. And I think there were a lot of folks who were offering either opinion or critique or positive or negative responses who hadn’t yet seen it, and so it was really hard, especially in those early days, to get a sense of like separating the fact from the fiction, what this exhibit actually is. I really wanted to see it for myself and and get back to Winnipeg for a bit before the weather got cold, and having the two of you in Winnipeg was a perfect opportunity for us to go together. I think we had I had a wonderful time with both of you. I think we had a lot of really great conversation, and it stirred up some things for me definitely. And some of our conversations where that’s actually not what I was expecting from myself, or expecting how I would feel during it, which those are always kind of the best experiences where something catches you by surprise or you learn something new, and so I wanted to get us together to talk about that because I think there’s probably a lot of people who have heard so much controversy and have not seen the exhibit and are probably wondering beyond the headlines and the outrage online. What actually is this exhibit? So let’s let’s let’s talk about that. I think first, you know, I was pretty, I was I I was surprised at the size of the exhibit. So I’m wondering, like Dave, maybe I’ll start with you. Do you want to talk about just like first of all I think you’ve been to the museum more than once I think both of you’ve been to the museum more than once it was my first time there so do you want to talk just a little bit about like the museum itself and then the Nakba exhibit itself and kind of what that whole space looks like

Dave B

sure so actually this was my first time really seeing the exhibits there I know it’s been around for a long time. I’m a bad Winnipegger, but yeah, I mean the museum itself is beautiful. It’s one of the most beautiful buildings, if not the single most beautiful building in the whole city. And so you go through, and it sort of meanders all these different ways. And some of the, I mean, there’s lots of exhibits, and many of them are very are a lot bigger. The Nagba exhibit is really very small. It almost reminded me of like a science fair sized like project almost. I think someone mentioned to me that there were 600 words, like 600 words total on the whole exhibit. So or somewhere around there, which is not surprising. It was essentially like four to eight paragraphs of text, and and then there was a video, and then there were some, I guess, artifacts from local Palestinians. So yeah, I mean, so that’s sort of what it was.

Maytal Kowalski

Is there anything to add? Anything that kind of like to express?

Esther B

Well I think it’s important to understand. I have kind of checked out this museum lot, so I volunteered at the very beginning of its inception, and I’ve been in and out a lot since. The place the exhibit is on the fifth floor, and that fifth floor is for moving exhibits. So it’s not for meant for permanent kind. It’s not a permanent space for exhibits, and it’s also it was as Dave said very small. I think that it gave the opportunity for Palestinians who are in Canada, in Winnipeg, in Canada, to talk a little bit about their displacement and their families’ displacement and what that meant from 4740, On, and I thought that was a really important piece because as you go through the museum, there are lots of other communities that have space to talk about their backgrounds and their histories, including our own, where there’s a really huge room plus a video room, plus changing some changing exhibits about the Holocaust. So, but we don’t. It’s true. Have anything present day in terms of what’s happening, and I think that’s something we it challenges us as a community to start looking at.

Maytal Kowalski

Right. Yeah. For sure. For sure. Yeah, so like you know, because I had heard, I remember hearing that it was a small room. Like before we went, I kept hearing it described as like it’s the exhibit is the small room, and like it kind of is a room in the sense that it’s a little bit enclosed with the walls, but the exhibit itself is literally only on the one wall. Like the wall behind it doesn’t have anything related to the exhibit, so it is it is tiny. Like it’s it’s it’s almost there’s a bit of like there’s like a feeling of like deflation, kind of that I’m like oh these four walls like this is what this is what we are all making a big deal about. But but but at the same time, just because it’s small doesn’t mean that it can’t be controversial. I’m not saying that I necessarily found it that that controversial, but but it is really small, and you know I I think that it does kind of bring up the question of when you have less space, how do you adequately tell a story? And Esther, I’m going to stick with you for a second because one of the things that I thought was so helpful for me going through the museum was because, as you said, you had volunteered in the early days. You really have an understanding of what the museum, like what the purpose of the museum is, what these exhibits are trying to show, and it really, it like changed my, it changed the the lens through which I was looking at all the exhibits, having you explain that, and I was wondering if you can speak a little bit more to that and kind of what the museum is attempting to do with with with what they’re showing and the stories that they’re telling.

Esther B

Okay, and this is my personal for

Maytal Kowalski

sure, for sure, yeah,

Esther B

feelings, not even feelings, my viewpoints as I’ve gone through, is I see the museum not as being a historical or political museum, which is often what our museums are, you know. And it is a museum to tell people stories, community stories, and so if we go through the museum, we basically see the stories of the First Nations, the stories of the immigrants coming to Canada, and and the human rights story around there. We see different people throughout history and how they impacted human rights in this country and in the world, so we have part of our story, which is the Holocaust story, and it’s pretty moving and it’s pretty important. And people spent a long, long time figuring it out, but the Palestinians don’t have their story, and this was an advantage I see for them to tell it from their perspective. The historical record has all kinds of different perspectives and foci, but this is people who are living in Winnipeg and living in Canada, and how they see what’s happened to them, and how they got to Canada, and what’s left, and so that was a really important thing for me. I think I also told you about the fact that that I had some orphans living with me after the Burundian War, so I knew about the Burundian story. That’s what they came with, and then I went to the museum, and they talked about the Rwandan War, and the Rwandan War was the Rwandans’ community story. It was different than the story I had heard from these young people, it was their story. If the Burundian community wants to add to that story, to put their story in, there’s space for them. There’s space for all kinds of different people. So I kind of enjoyed seeing and hearing the Palestinian story. Of course, I had heard different stories, so I had different ideas. But it was really enlightening to also see their story.

Maytal Kowalski

Yeah, I mean, I think one of the one of the amazing things about like Winnipeg is such a city of. Of immigrants, you know, my on my mother’s side of the family, they had been in Winnipeg for quite a few generations. But my father was the the first of his, you know, he he was the first generation that was born in Canada in Winnipeg. His parents originally from from Poland, so you know, I think that it is very much the case. I mean, this is the case across all of Canada, but I do really feel that it is there is something you know a little bit more specific to Winnipeg, where there is such a high concentration of of immigration, continued immigration. We all I think are raised in some way with those stories of where our family came from to come to Winnipeg. So I do see the benefit in having this museum in Winnipeg that tells, like you’re saying, like it’s not about historical facts necessarily of different conflicts. It’s about hey, here are all the people that make up this city, which is really what Canada is all about. And here, here are their stories of you know what what brought them here. And and you’re right, there is a Palestinian community, and up until this exhibit, those were not stories that that we heard. Now, that being said, and keeping that in mind, I mean, I didn’t have any issue necessarily hearing her like personal stories. In fact, like you said, it was it was a real gift to get to hear stories of Palestinians now living in Winnipeg and how the experience of the Nakba, you know, like changed the course of their family for forever and brought them, you know, and how they ended up in Winnipeg and you know all of that. But it was hard for me to separate that sometimes personal story will get interpreted as historical fact when it isn’t, and I’m just wondering, Dave. Maybe I’ll go to you. Like, how did you feel about kind of what you were hearing in those stories? What you were seeing? Did it feel? And did it feel like you know? It was. It was kind of the situation where we were hearing. We were hearing a diff. We usually hear the Jewish or Israeli story to the exclusion of the Palestinian story. Here we were hearing the Palestinian story to the exclusion of the Israeli story. I just wonder how that sat with you, or how you felt with that.

Dave B

Yeah, I think you know. At the time we spoke about this, I think my biggest takeaway, sort of as a political science student in my youth and studying Israel Palestine, I found it to be non. There was it was so small that there wasn’t enough context. It was sort of a non contextual story of Palestine, and that part sort of bothered me. But I think, from what I know, reading Israeli scholars is that what I think what the content of not necessarily the stories, but they’re they’re sort of an explainer of like what this is. That’s those 600 words. To me, it was like mostly accurate. I think. I think if you have an issue with Palestinians existing and and the Palestinian story in general, then yes, you will have an issue with this. If you’re okay with the Palestinian story and still believe in Israel’s right to exist, blah blah blah, then this shouldn’t really be that big of a deal. And I think that’s and I think that to me it seemed like the controversy was about was maybe not knowing or dancing on that line where where people’s constituents coming from. There are definitely elements of our community that don’t want to hear the Palestinian story at all and totally discount it, and I think that’s a detriment to our community. Again, that doesn’t mean that Israel shouldn’t exist or anything like that. I strongly believe that it should, but I think that that like the the story that was told or the words that were there were were like so were mostly accurate. There wasn’t really any big there wasn’t anything that I was like I think from my research that’s factually incorrect. Like that didn’t really happen. There were some glaring omissions. I think that maybe that was purposeful.

Maytal Kowalski

do you wanna do you wanna talk wade into that one? What did you feel were the glaring omissions?

Dave B

Yeah. So I mean, the the biggest one. I guess there’s two two big ones. The the single biggest one was they talk about october 7 and 1200 people dying, but they don’t talk about who died. So it was like a very odd. It was like really weird. Like if you know anything about October 7, if you know just a cursory knowledge that something happened on October 7, I think you would know that Israelis and Jews died on that day, and this exhibit chose not to specifically, it seems, not to mention that that it just said 1200 people died. What people? Who? What are we? Who are we talking about here? Right. So that is weird. That that was like very strange. And then the other part is that they basically say the conflict. Started in 1948 against Israel, which that is like sort of a factually incorrect thing. So if you know I said before most of it was factually correct, that was incorrect. Also, starting the conflict in 1948 also isn’t really true, right? It sort of happens well before that, and so and also Israel didn’t control those territories until 1967, so that part was a little strange, and sort of seemed to be blaming Israel for things that maybe they didn’t actually really do

Dave B

I wouldn’t expect an exhibit like this to own up to any sort of self blame, but I think if we’re going to be if if we as Jews are going to criticize the Israeli government of today, which we do every chance we get because they are deserving of criticism, then I think it would be reasonable also for Palestinians to do the same. And I think one of the things about 1947 and 1948 is that Arab leadership failed their people, and that wasn’t mentioned ever. You know,

Maytal Kowalski

yeah, yeah, yeah. Esther, any any additional reflections on that, or anything that Dave hasn’t mentioned that kind of that you’d that you’d want to mention?

Esther B

No, I think it was similar for me. Is I was a little. There was a disconnect for me that I was only hearing the Palestinian version without context, and so the. I mean, I had the context, but other people don’t necessarily have the context, and so there was a bit of a disconnect because of that, but I’m not sure that that isn’t the case for many of the exhibits or many of the people talking online, etc. So I really wasn’t something that totally, you know.

Maytal Kowalski

Well, and you know, I think it’s interesting. So we’re having this conversation actually today is Thursday, october 8, and we were before we started recording. We were having a conversation about like various statements that have been put out by various politicians on October 7, and this question of can we can we tell the story of october 7, without mentioning Palestinians, and can we make it a story just of just of what happened on that day to Israel and to Jews? I think there would probably be a question there. You know, I think it kind of works in the same way, right? It’s like, and and I think to Dave’s point too, like if you wanna, if we wanna say that every that things need like this is such a this is one of the most complicated intractable conflicts probably in history, where do we where where do we start the story? What context is needed and provided? And I guess I would just ask maybe maybe I’ll go back to Dave actually and ask that question. Like, is it okay? We’re talking about our personal feelings. We’re talking about the fact that it felt it felt like stuff was being omitted. But like, do we feel that that’s okay ultimately for someone to be able to tell their story? Or like, in what context should we be okay with someone saying, “I just want to focus on this part of a story.

Dave B

Yeah, so I think you know before in our conversation, I was saying people I think are saying you know all these statements october 7. Like can’t why does why do the Palestinians always need to be mentioned? Can’t it just be about Jewish loss of life? And I think it can be. I I don’t know that all these statements always need to be in the context of Palestinians. But in that same vein, if you have something about Palestinians, why does it always need to be in the context of Israel? Can’t it just be their stories? And I think it can be just their stories. These two things seem to be more a little bit more than that. To me, they were sort of like purposeful omissions. Like the Israelis aren’t aren’t worth mentioning. the The loss of Israeli life isn’t worth mentioning because they’re not worth it. Like that part was weird. I think if I think if October 7 happened and Hamas terrorists killed a bunch of Palestinians. Also, I think that would be part of the story on that one specific day. If we’re talking about the war in general that started a few days later, okay, then then that’s a different story. And what has happened since then is a different story. But if we’re just talking about that one day, it seems really purposeful to admit to omit that Israelis were the ones and Jews were the ones that were killed. So that part seemed really odd to me. And and I like I said, I think you can talk about Palestine without talking about Israel. I think that’s okay. But this one seemed to be more like it seemed to be a little more than that to me. I think okay,

Maytal Kowalski

yeah,

Dave B

yeah.

Maytal Kowalski

So that’s actually really interesting because I think kind of what you’re getting at is like there is a difference between the full the full scope of context and between even just like you can still omit a lot of context if you need if you need to or want to, but you can’t change the facts of the context that you are providing.

Dave B

if anything, actually, now that I think about it, I’m wondering why october 7 need to be mentioned at all. The Palestinian story should stand on its own, not in the context of what’s happening now. Palestinians have suffered for many, many years, and as Jews, we need to recognize that. And as a world community, we need to recognize that. Why does October seven need to be mentioned at all? Like, yes, there’s this current conflict that’s happening that has happened over the past three years, and there’s been more loss of life then. But, but that’s just sort of you know, as we know, that’s sort of just today’s conflict. Like, what about all the other ones that have happened? And so maybe it actually would have been a more a more powerful exhibit had October seven not been mentioned in a way, because

Maytal Kowalski

I can imagine I can I can already predict. Esther and I are like laughing because we can already predict the backlash from the Jewish organized Jewish community, if october 7 wasn’t mentioned, and I do think that like that was, I I imagine I am not saying this based on any fact. This is what I imagine. I imagine that so much of putting this together felt like we’re we’re going to be damned if we do and damned if we don’t. You know, I think that there was there was I think that there is a careful tiptoeing around what is mentioned and why to make sure that the outrage machine could be quelled as much as possible. Which, which I actually think probably you shouldn’t do. I think that like if there’s going to be controversy no matter what, then like stay stay clear with your with your principles and and what you’re going to do. Otherwise, you kind of end up in a situation where you’re trying to please everyone and you please no one, which I think maybe happened here. But I do agree, and I think we’ll we’ll link in the email when we send this out. There there was a statement or a quote from someone at the museum that I will pull up so that we have it accurate about using the word “people. Where they said, like, I think the reason that they did it, from what I recall, was that they said, you know, that it’s a well-established fact that it wasn’t just Israelis or Jews who died in the Hamas attacks on October 7, which I find really not compelling because that is true. The majority, though, were Jewish Israelis, and also, you know, the way that we always worded at J Space Canada when we talk about it is we say something like Israelis and foreign nationals, because even and Israelis doesn’t necessarily mean Israeli Jews, right? We know like someone like Awadal Dawashi, who you know, paramedic who was tragically killed trying to save his friends or successfully saving many of his friends and then being killed himself at Nova. He is he is an Arab Israeli. He is an Israeli. So Israeli and foreign nationals. You know there are ways to kind of word it. So I agree. It felt like a very glaring omission, and I’m not super buying the the rationale as to why it was chosen.

Esther B

Yeah, no, I would I would totally agree that that was that was an omission that was if it was going to be in, it needed yeah context,

Maytal Kowalski

right? Agree.

Dave B

That’s kind of what I’m saying. Don’t even mention it at all, and then and then we don’t have this conversation for the last 15 minutes about it, right? So it’s sort of like, and it doesn’t change the context of Palestinian suffering and Palestinian stories. The stories that were there and the video that was shown wasn’t about october 7 or anything that happened in Gaza. It was all stuff that had happened in 1948, 1967, like it was all very historical stuff. Older people talking about their. It wasn’t like 20 year old being like my house got bombed in Gaza. Like there was none of that. So sort of the you only have 600 words. Why mention it at all?

Maytal Kowalski

Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, that’s a really good point. The the only other thing that I felt, you know, again, like really trying to disentangle the personal story from the historical facts. Because one of the video testimonies, the woman said something about Palestinians living under occupation for the last nearly 80 years, and like to me, I’m like, well, the military occupation started in ‘67. Now I understand if you want to make the argument that it felt like an occupation. We know that there were military curfews. We know that there there have you know there there the the rights and freedoms for Palestinians who then became citizens of Israel post ‘48 and stayed looked much different than how there. Jewish counterparts were treated. That’s not the that is not the the correct term for occupation, though. That is that is discrimination, and that is inequality, and it is all of those things. And so again, it’s kind. It was for me one of those things where I’m like, okay, I can I can say I’m okay with this description because if that’s what it feels like personally to you, and this is your personal story, I’m not going to argue your personal story with you. But you know, one of the things, Esker, that that you brought up, and we were kind of talking about as we kind of finished the exhibit and sat, and then watched other people who definitely weren’t Jewish or Palestinian walking through it, or most likely weren’t Jewish or Palestinian walking through it, is we were like, man, it would be so interesting to find out how they’re interpreting that, or even like I like I I wish we had asked someone, but like I would be so curious to ask someone like, oh, you heard that woman talking about Palestinians living under occupation? What do you think that that means? Like when you imagine that territory, or when you imagine the rule of law, what is what do you think it means to live under occupation? Like I can guess that probably people, most people, would not understand or be able to kind of talk about lands occupied in ‘67 versus internationally recognized borders of the Green Line, et cetera, et cetera. And so, I don’t know, but like it’s, it’s again, it’s like because it’s a personal story. Like, are we going to start getting into it? But then at the same time, I do have a little bit of that feeling of like, no, like there’s there are things to criticize about Israel. We criticize the occupation all the time, but like, do it right because now this, and then also like I don’t want it to invalidate the whole thing, right? Like now again, we’re gonna spend time talking about occupation 48 to 67 when really we should be focusing on the fact that those lands, those those those territories are still occupied, and you know, continuously being annexed and attempts at ethnic cleansing and successes at ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from those lands. That it’s like, on the one hand, I get that this is a personal story. On the other hand, it’s like, how does that personal story then affect how people understand the region itself and the facts on the ground?

Esther B

And that is for me the difference between this being personal stories and not history and not political analysis, etc. Is for them it felt the same pre 67 as post 67. They were still shackled to their spaces without being able to move freely, and that. So, if it’s going to be their personal story, then keep it their personal story. If it’s going to be bigger stories than make them accurate, you know, and that is part of the problem. I mean, that’s part of what the exhibit kind of had to figure out, and yeah, you know, the real difficulties they had with moving it along, and the difficulties the the museum is finding right now.

Maytal Kowalski

Yep. Yep. So, but I do think. I mean, I’m so I’m I ultimately like I’m so heartened that it was there, and I just think about how often I feel like our story isn’t her, and like I mean that very broadly, whatever the Jewish story is, and we’ll talk about that, you know, maybe a little bit more in a bit. But like I think about how much it touches me when I see a story that’s important to me about my history being told and people getting to see it, and so I felt the same. Like as soon as we kind of walked, like walked into that space, and all of a sudden you’re seeing Palestinian identity on display so, so, so proudly and so unapologetically, and knowing that my country and my hometown has been a safe haven for these people who did have to escape, like that was really touching for me. I felt I, I ultimately overall, like we can nitpick at some of the pieces, but overall, it just did make me so happy that this story was was being told. So I really do think that like if you can get a chance to go to Winnipeg and see it, I think folks really should. I think that even if it’s like I think especially if it’s going to be challenging for you, like go and like have that challenge for yourself. I think that that’s so important when we talk about like how we move forward in these conversations. So for me, I mean, it then opened up a bunch of stuff for me of like, well, wait, the only Jewish story being told is the Holocaust story, and you know what are some other Jewish stories that are that are being told, and you know, like, and then I don’t, I don’t. It’s it’s it’s just it’s crazy because we’re talking about a museum that tells the story of human rights violations, and we know that Jews throughout history, I mean, we have been persecuted, our human rights have been violated. In so many different ways, in so many different places, and those all become stories of various Jewish communities in the diaspora. I don’t know that we can take up a whole museum talking about all of our different stories, but like it is, you know, we do focus on the Holocaust. I think the exclusion of so many other stories. So I think even just being at the museum itself and getting to walk through it and have all of these other thoughts come up. We’re so, I mean, I’m I’m so happy I had that experience. I think I could have spent days kind of in that museum and just just reflecting. Curious curious for you. Actually, I’ll go to you, Dave, because as you said, it was your first time really going through going through the museum. What did you? Yeah, just kind of like summary thoughts. What did you think overall?

Dave B

Yeah, I mean, I again, I I thought it was beautiful. It’s a beautiful building, but I I found and maybe I was expecting not this type of museum where we’re telling personal stories, but I sort of found all of the exhibits that I really looked at to be all not none of them had enough context, including the Holocaust one. You know, I would argue that the Holocaust section was actually kind of like it’s. It might be the biggest section of that museum, but in terms of like the Holocaust museums I’ve been to, it is tiny. Sure, yeah, and like the and they sort of focus on Auschwitz a little bit because maybe that’s either the stories that have been told by people here, or that’s the people know the most. But like, they’re you know Treblinka. If we’re gonna really get into the weeds here, like Treblinka killed more people than Auschwitz, right? And there, there isn’t much mention of that. So once I saw that, I was like, oh, I guess nothing. There’s not a ton of context to anything here. Okay, so this is still in line with what they do, so on the one hand, I would have wanted more context to the Palestinian story, but as a grandchild of Holocaust survivors, I would have also wanted more context to the Holocaust stuff as well. Yeah, and I and there wasn’t, and maybe I just didn’t see it. You know, we went through it sort of quickly, but I guess, and maybe this is there. So maybe I’m not speaking right. But there wasn’t like anything about like why people hate each other, or at least I didn’t see that. You know, like why is what the need for a human rights museum is so that we can learn about other people and the suffering they’ve gone to, so that we can forge a better. I would think, so we can forge a better world for the future and our children and the whole thing, right? Where we, where we, a world without racism and hate and all that sort of stuff. But they, I don’t, I didn’t see a section where they talked about like why people hate each other, and that’s something that I’ve like sort of thought about.

Maytal Kowalski

Did we miss it, Esther?

Esther B

They didn’t talk about why they hate each other, but they talked about there was a whole wall, and we did walk straight through it because we were in a rush. But between the Holocaust Museum part and the Rwandan that map thing that we looked at, there was a whole wall of talking about human rights and why they were important, and the people that fought for them over the years, and it was a Canadian, in fact, that put the Human Rights Declaration Act or whatever it’s together, and so they did. It wasn’t. It was the main room between all of the genocides, and so and there was also there were there was another sort of display about some of the main human rights kind of violations about you know around disabled people around trans, around you know just prejudice with black, white, etc. and with Jews. But so you could press buttons and ask questions, and you were able to get some responses to how was how they felt and how it was handled. But it was that room that we literally race through. So next time you go...

Maytal Kowalski

yeah. I mean, I think that that’s a really interesting thing too. Is that like the UN Declaration of Human Rights, like it has not always existed. This concept of human rights enshrined as some sort of international law is is relatively new, right? So there is something really special about what this museum is doing as well of trying to like you know really kind of talk about okay what now that we have that like what does that mean and how do we tell stories and how do we uphold this law Esther any and what are your kind of final final takeaways and and final thoughts

Esther B

I guess my final takeaways is it’s really important as well as and you said this to go and see the museum the the place the Palestinian story yourself and to look at it and to decide in terms of if you’re Jewish. What other stories do we have that you’d like them to put forward? And let’s look at what can be put forward. I mean, I think the Arabs in the Jews in Arab lands is a huge one that that story has not been told and could be told. So it really, but from where I see it, I think it’s people, individuals, and groups of people that help the museum make decisions about where they’re to go. And so, people feel strongly about different stories. It’s really important to bring them forward and to put in the time and energy to help make it happen, and so I see no no problem between that. But I think the major focus, and that’s what I’m hearing over and over again. This is not a museum of historical human problems, and you know and how they’ve been resolved. This is a museum that looks at individual or small groups of people’s their life stories and what they want others to hear and to know about, and I think that that’s really an important focus too. And I wouldn’t take it away from this museum at all. So even with its problems and its, you know, ways of, you know, making themselves better as a museum, I think they have to be proud of what they are, and we are proud of them.

Maytal Kowalski

Totally agree. Could not agree more. I think what you just said is super important. Like the stories that people want to tell and what they want people to know about them. You know, I think in Canada we do really pride ourselves on being a country of immigrants and being welcoming to immigrants, I mean, we don’t have the best record record record with it all the time, but I do think you know it is something that like you know immigration as a part of Canadian culture, I think, has is is quite ingrained in who we are and and how we want to see ourselves. Right, this is something we talk at J Space about a lot of like not only who we are but who we want to be or how we want people to see us. And I think that if we’re going to, if if if the story of immigration to build the country to what it is is important to us and something we hold dear, it can’t just be the stories that we want or the stories that we are comfortable with, but also those people who are coming as immigrants, what is their story? What do they want us to know? What may we not know about them? And the fact that this museum is, I think, trying to trying to tackle that in a way that is both global and very very local is is really incredible. So Esther and Dave, thank you so much for coming with me to the museum and for making the weather so nice when I was in Winnipeg, it was it was a beautiful weekend when I was there. I’ll give you guys some credit for that. And thank you for thank you for thank you for joining me for this conversation. I’m I’m really appreciative. I’m appreciative that we got to talk through it so much, and I hope that we’ve maybe encouraged some others to check out the exhibit as well.

Esther B

Thanks a lot for having the conversation,

Maytal Kowalski

of course, of course, awesome. Thanks,

Esther B

thanks.

This transcript is auto-generated and lightly edited. Some spelling, grammar, and syntax errors may occur.