Jon and Maytal are joined by guest Ofer Matan to discuss the early outcomes and possibilities of the Israeli election.
For a downloadable, audio-only recording, click here.
Transcript:
Maytal Kowalski
Hello, Jon, and joined today also by Ofer. Hello to you both.
Jon Allen
Hi, Maytal. Good to see you.
Ofer Matan
You too.
Jon Allen
On a rather depressing day.
Maytal Kowalski
No spoilers right off the bat, Jon.
Ofer Matan
Hi, guys. Nice to see you. I hope it will still become good. I have some remains of optimism in me, though it’s not very big.
Maytal Kowalski
Oh, this is okay. This is the balance we’re usually missing. This is nice, and let me use that to actually. I’ll turn over. It’s usually Jon and I in this conversation, but we have a special guest joining us from Israel, actually, right now. So, Ofer, why don’t I, if you want to introduce yourself really quick, and then we can jump into what we’re here to talk about today.
Ofer Matan
So, hi, I’m actually in Israel right now, though I live in Toronto. I’ve been covering Canadian stories for Haaretz in English in the last two months or so. We actually have a Haaretz Canada weekly newsletter that everyone should join. And yeah, I’ve I’ve worked in in the Israeli human rights sector until a few months ago, and I came here to vote. And in a few days’ time, I’ll be back in Toronto.
Maytal Kowalski
Wonderful. Well, thank you for heading back to to vote. My mom is actually also there doing doing the same thing and sending sending me pictures of all your adventures. And I wish I could I wish I could be there as well. Even though I mean, we’ll get into everything that happened yesterday, and you’re joining us in the evening. I think it’s around 6pm. for you there in Israel. So obviously, there’s been you know you’ve got the coverage from today that we can talk about as well as everything that was that was happening yesterday. So thank you so much for joining us, Efrain, for taking the time, and John as always. And I’m actually going to turn it over to you right away, John. I want to ask you. Let’s just start with kind of a high-level analysis of where everything shook out and where we sit right now with the with the Israeli elections.
Jon Allen
Sure. Thanks. Well, I mean, you know, there’s always good news and bad news. The good news was that this was the largest overall turnout by Israelis in any election? I think since the early 1970s, and for the Palestinian Israelis, it was the largest turnout ever, over 80 percent. Yeah. So that’s good news. Then there was sort of good news at the time of the exit polls, where it it looked like while Bibi Netanyahu’s Likud was the largest party, it seemed that the opposition coalition was closer to getting to a majority, not at a majority by any stretch, but closer. Unfortunately, with according to Haaretz, 85.6% of the votes now counted. The story is 53. seats for the Bibi coalition, 48 for the Eisenkot coalition, we’ll call it, and an amazing 19 seats for the Palestinian Israelis, Arab Israelis, the two parties together. Point out that the joint list is number four, tied with the Lapid Bennett party in in total number of seats. So, needless to say, for people like me who were hoping for a change government and and a fairly clear mandate, maybe not predicting a majority because none of the polls suggested there would be a majority for an Eisenkot coalition, but certainly the the current results are far from what I, for one, had hoped. And going forward, you know there are many possibilities, but the reality seems to me that the only the the only viable possibility for a change government and getting rid of Bibi Smotrich and Ben Gvir is some relationship with the Palestinian Arabs at this point, whether it’s coalition with them, whether it’s support from the outside. With them, whether it’s having X number abstaining and some supporting, it’s hard to know. But as we move to the point where parties are going to meet with the president, something of that nature has to come Together, because the alternatives are some kind of coalition between Likud and Eisenkot, which I hope will not happen. We’ve seen that story play out before, and it didn’t play out very well for Benny Gantz, And also, you know, the other possibility is is Bibi getting the nod somehow, although it does not seem likely unless unless somebody from the Eisenhower coalition bolts and joins him, and then of course the the final option is going to new elections, and going to new elections means Bibi in place for at least 90 days, and who knows what could happen in those 90 days. You know, just looking forward to a Trump-Israel attack on Iran, et cetera, et cetera, and you know a continuation of of the kinds of policies that that some of us abhor. Yeah, I’ll leave it there.
Maytal Kowalski
Oh, sure. That’s I mean that’s a really good, really good thorough analysis laying out some three possible scenarios there. Ofer, is there anything that you want to add, especially from kind of what you’re seeing on the ground there?
Ofer Matan
I mean, I agree with Jon Allen that it was kind of expected based on the polls in the last few months that Eisenkot and the rest of the Jewish opposition will not be able to form a coalition without adding at least one of the Palestinian parties. The numbers last night, when it showed 52 seats for the Eisenkot, the Jewish opposition, and 50 for the Netanyahu supporters, then a scenario of Eisenkot forming a minority coalition with the support of the Palestinian parties made some sense because they did have more numbers than the Netanyahu supporters. But now, when they’re down to 47, I find it hard to believe that they will form a coalition. As in, I think they need to add Ra’am, the Mansour Abbas Party, actually to be part of a coalition, and then have a minority coalition of around 5455 seats, and then have the joint list supporting it without being part of it, I don’t see a scenario where they’ll go for a minority coalition of less than 50 seats out of 120, and I doubt it if President Herzog will let Eisenkot be the first one trying to form a government, given if that will be his framework. And the heads of the parties don’t need to only say who are they recommending to be the one getting the the right to form a coalition. They need to also say who are they objecting, who will they go with, and kind of explain their little strategies and do and don’ts. And that’s how the president will make decisions. So I believe that if Eisenkot tells Herzog, “I’m adding Ra’am with me, we’re 54, 55. The joint list with 12 seats are supporting from outside. It’s stable enough. He’ll get the green light. I doubt if he’ll get a green light with 19 seats supporting from the outside, it’s too shaky in my mind.
Maytal Kowalski
So let’s let’s pause for a second. I want to ask you to today. I think you’re you’re bringing up something really important and something that maybe folks don’t understand in terms of, or that we need to give a little bit more clarity to in terms of working with those Arab parties. And I do just want to clarify because we are using some terms interchangeably when we are talking about Palestinian or Palestinian Arab or Arab parties. We are talking about Palestinian citizens of Israel. We are talking about all the parties that are still Israeli citizens, and we know that the Arab-Israeli or Palestinian citizens of Israel community is not a monolith in terms of the terms that they use to describe themselves. Some say Arab-Israeli, some say Palestinian citizens of Israel, and so we too are kind of using those terms interchangeably. But we are always talking about, obviously, the Israeli leaders who are running Arab parties in the Knesset. So, can you explain then, Ofer, when you’re talking about because this is this was what happened with the with the change government. With Lapid and Bennett, where while they did work with the Arab parties, worked with Ra’am, they supported from the outside. Can you clarify the difference between what it means, what you’re talking about when you say actually sitting in the coalition versus supporting from the outside?
Ofer Matan
The difference might look not so big in terms of in both cases, people are voting for the existence of a government, whether they’re part of it or not. But in order to have a government in the Israeli system, you need to have a majority of the people that vote in the parliament supporting this coalition. So if we have 19 seats of Arab-Israeli slash Palestinian representatives. If theoretically they all decide not to show up to work, and then there is a vote yes or no for the coalition with 101 Knesset members, it’s enough that the coalition will have majority from that one 101 people, and that’s enough. It’s not a big difference being in the coalition or outside of the coalition. One might say the main difference is if your party gets some ministers or not. But historically, the Palestinian parties in the Israeli politics often, even in cases where they were part of a coalition, they still technically were supporting it from the outside. And in terms of the Israeli-Palestinian discourse, they see it as as not going full on, as in not being actually part of the coalition, and it’s relevant to the discussion in the Palestinian society, which is an old discussion, whether they’re normalizing the occupation and the balance of power between Jews and Palestinians by being part of the Knesset or even being part of the government, which is obviously a higher level of involvement. So they would probably be fine with supporting it from the outside, but Ra’am, I think, would love to be part of the coalition as well, and to get some minister and vice ministers roles. So that that’s the difference.
Jon Allen
And and let me say that the Arab parties have already made it quite clear that they are prepared to support. They haven’t gone into details, but I agree completely with Ofer. Ra’am would be in as they were with the change government, and would love to get a seat at the table. And one of the parties in the joint list, of course, has As a Jew, former police high senior official in the police, who would also, it seems to me, you know, be an ideal candidate to participate. But I agree entirely with what was said. I would just add one other thing: there are still 600,000 double, what are called double envelope votes to be counted. These are the votes of diplomats and and military people and others who are abroad. It’s not clear to me how what the analysis of how they’re going to vote. I would say if they’re diplomats, they might be voting opposition, and if they’re military, they might be voting BB. But who knows what those votes contain? But that’s a significant number of votes and could change the numbers one way or the other, or you know leave them where they they are, but yeah, it’s that won’t be known for at least a few days.
Ofer Matan
right. If I can just add just one thing regarding that, usually the assumption in the political discourse in Israel is that those those double envelopes don’t add any seats to the Arab parties since it’s soldiers and diplomats. So we’ll probably see the Arab parties go lower than 19 because of those envelopes. And historically, soldiers usually vote more right than left.
Maytal Kowalski
Right. Okay. Very interesting. Yeah. So we’re still waiting. We’re waiting on a lot of a lot of answers, obviously. I did want to ask about. I want to stay on this issue of the Arab parties for a second because I think that this is a really interesting story that’s that’s coming out of that’s coming out of this election, and I’m just wondering to the extent that anyone can say or anyone can analyze, as we said, I think it was 80% voter turnout from from the Arab population in Israel. That population is about 20% of of the Israeli populace. So, you know, I I want to ask. I think I want to ask two questions. The first that I want to ask is, to the best of our kind of ability to analyze it, what led to that? What led? What were some of the factors that led to a historic turnout from this from this community? And then I think the the second question that I want to ask is like, when we talk about this idea, I understand what you’re saying, Ofer, in terms of like historically, if you supported from the outside but you didn’t sit in the coalition, then you weren’t normalizing, you know, either the governance of Israel or Israel being a Jewish majority state or any of these things. You know, when you’re 20% of a population, it seems to it seems to me. I’m obviously speaking from my Jewish diaspora privilege here, but it seems to me that like being normalized within society is what you want because you do want that seat at the table. So I’m just wondering. I mean, I recognize that we are sitting here; we do not have a Palestinian voice with us. But to the extent that we can kind of analyze some of the changes on the ground, can we dig into that a little bit more. Why don’t I start with Ofer and then go to John? Just in terms of, yeah, what what are those changes that that we’re seeing in the in the Arab society in Israel, and where do we see it going?
Ofer Matan
Yeah. So I’ll start with saying that around 10 years ago there was a shift in the strategy of the way the leaders of the Arab parties think and act, led by Ayman Odeh, the ex-head of the joint list, and he basically led a strategy saying we want to be part of the decision makers in one way or another, and we think that’s the best way to improve our situation as a minority, and we want to be part of the decision making in Israeli society. So it’s been kind of the state of mind among most of the Arab parties in the last 10 years or so, and in the last two or three elections, we have Ra’am that is officially saying that they basically only interest focus on internal and civil issues, and not on on a nationalistic Palestinian issues, which that’s their difference between them and the joint list. And regarding your first question, I think the main reason that a lot of Palestinians came to vote is that their lives became much worse in the last four years. I’m putting aside their feelings and sadness about what’s happening in Gaza, which is a big thing. I’m putting that aside for a second. I think that the numbers of people that were killed by organized crime inside the Palestinian society in Israel, and the way Israel is treating Palestinian prisoners in Israeli prisons, which it’s not only terrorists from Gaza or from the West Bank. It might be also people from Haifa, Nazareth, which are Palestinians and wrote a post that seems to be inciting for the police. They might find themselves for three months in a prison being tortured on a daily basis. Those two reasons made them feel that they have to vote, and it’s both related to Ben-Gvir. I mean, Ben-Gvir, in a way, did acts that are not only symbolically annoying Palestinians; they’re actually endangering the lives of almost every Palestinian living in Israel, and that’s why so many of them went to vote.
Jon Allen
I would I would just add maybe a couple of other things and and certain irony here. In addition to that, you’ll recall that the Bibi coalition tried to disqualify the parties and individuals, and succeeded at the Supreme Court in disqualifying one individual. And if you add to that the classic Bibi call, which was amplified as the campaign went on, beware of the Palestinians, beware of the Palestinians, and it really started to come to a head at the end. Of course, with his, you know, as if the atomic bomb was a combination of Iran and the the Palestinians. It I think and I actually heard from some that it motivated them to come out. They wanted to to demonstrate that they were not going to be afraid and that they wanted to assert themselves. Of course, the irony is that, in some senses, I think it worked again for Bibi. I think they did extremely well, and they did come out. But I think for post. October seven Israelis, many of them maybe we in the diaspora can’t understand, but many of them fear the Palestinians, the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, and the Palestinians beside them. And I think that unfortunately, you know they they voted for Bibi and that coalition for many reasons. But I think that was part of it, unfortunately. Yeah, and we’ll see how it plays out. And and I mean, one thing to talk about also, Maytal, is who in the coalition, in the anti Bibi coalition, is is prepared to to change their views. Yair Galon doesn’t have to change his, and maybe Eisenkot doesn’t. But some others are going to have to change their views if they’re going to rely on those Arab Israelis or Palestinian Israelis.
Maytal Kowalski
So let me ask exactly that, because thank you. That’s a perfect segue to what I wanted to say next, because I think we’re talking about all these different scenarios that we could see. Obviously, I think that like for folks like us and like-minded like-minded individuals, kind of you know hoping to see like also participation, obviously of of Arab Israelis. That’s that’s super important, and you know this rhetoric, as you were, as you alluded to, Jon, like this rhetoric of fear mongering about Arabs turning out to the poll. This is not new for for Netanyahu and for the right wing. But you know, a coalition. We have to remember this is also what happened with the the last change government, and exactly kind of what you’re alluding to, John. That even a coalition with the Arab parties with either support from the inside or the outside. We still have a coalition that exists that we will see people like Naftali Bennett, who’s like former head of the Yesha Council, right? Like settler himself believes in you know the the vision of Greater Israel, and you know, no, he’s he’s not a two-stater. He does see, he does believe that that that Jews are entitled to sovereignty over all the land, from the river to the sea. And then we’ll see Golan on the left, and potentially even further, we’ll see Mansour Abbas. So even if they do form that coalition, how shaky is it? And and and how how what are what’s the probability? I know this is like a really difficult thing, obviously, to predict. I’m not looking for scientific analysis, but like, is that a coalition? Given everything that you’re talking about, John, in terms of the fear of an Israeli society after october 7. Is it possible that such a coalition can even hold on for a significant amount of time, or do we see a coalition that then ultimately a year later leads to Israelis going back to the polls? Let’s start with Jon on that one, and then we’ll go to Ofer.
Jon Allen
Well, yeah. I mean, unstable. Yes. Will there be efforts to try and peel people off, yes. Will it ever come together? Will Avigdor Lieberman agree? Question mark. More chance of Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid agreeing since they’ve already done it once. But so those those are the questions. I guess my answer is let them stick together as long as they can set up a commission of inquiry, redress some of the threats to the independence of the judiciary, Pass the law that ends the exemption. In other words, get a hold of of parliament, get a hold of the government, do some positive things that I think all Israelis would frankly agree with, and then worry about whether or not you know you can stick together on some you know really tough questions going forward, but no question it it it it’s not stable. It’s not 61 votes or 65 votes or whatever. Yeah. Yeah. But yeah.
Maytal Kowalski
Yeah. What do you think, Ofer?
Ofer Matan
I agree. with Jon that it’s pretty shaky, and I think that unlike the change coalition few years ago, I think Eisenkot, if he’ll go for such scenario, he will do it without expecting it to last for four years. He said that he might go for a minority government in order to, as John said, put on some some new laws that can kind of change the horrible situation that the right wing government did, and then hopefully have some more parties from the other side joining his coalition in the future. I think he mainly his big hope is that those if they’ll pass some rules that that are undermining what Netanyahu’s coalition did in the last four years, including a law that does not allow a person that is under charge under chargers to run to be prime minister, he hopes that it will make Netanyahu to kind of go for some deal with the state about his trials, move aside, and then he’ll be happy to add the Likud to the coalition, which a lot of people that voted for him would not like the Likud to be in. But he sees it that way, as if Netanyahu is not there, it kosherizes the Likud to be brought into the coalition, and then he won’t be dependent on some support from Palestinian parties, and then it will be more stable. But it can definitely run for a year and then go for another elections. Yeah, that’s for sure.
Maytal Kowalski
Okay, interesting. Let’s switch gears for the last question here. Let’s switch gears just a little bit. As I mentioned off the top, we have Ofer here, you’re in Israel. It’s it’s evening there for you. You’ve been there, I think, for for a while. I want to ask you just kind of outside of the analysis, what’s what’s the mood like? I I know we saw like you know some some really large protests once again, primarily in Tel Aviv for you know calling for change, calling to kind of kind of hearkening back to the pre october 7 anti-judicial coup protests that we saw. You know what are you just sensing? I think you’re you’re you said you’re you’re in the center of the country. You’re in Ramat Gan. What are you sensing? What’s the mood like? What are people talking about? What’s what? What have you been? What have you been hearing from family, friends, etc.?
Ofer Matan
I’ve been in Tel Aviv in the last 12 days. I can say that I arrived to Tel Aviv less more pessimistic than I found myself last night, five minutes before the voting ended. Being in Tel Aviv in the last week or so was quite inspiring in a way because the city is packed with people that came from overseas, like a lot of people like me, like a lot, and it really brings optimism to the people who live here and are happy to see people like me coming to support. And also for me, I mean, you saw so many people from from the past suddenly in the streets. I went to my old bar, and all like the people from 15 years ago were there. I don’t even know who lives abroad and who lives here anymore, but everyone are kind of back in town, and I heard so many kids speaking in English and their dads answering Hebrew in the street. Like it’s it’s definitely a phenomenon that you see in the streets, and it did bring some optimism. I guess in other parts of the country, the feeling was different. So there was this feeling that the the poll the the ballots ballots right where you go to vote was so packed we stood for almost an hour in line to vote so there was some optimism and today after people went to sleep thinking that it’s 52 to the Eisenkot supporters 50 to Netanyahu and 18 to the Arab parties and realized that around five more seats went to Netanyahu’s side during the night. I guess you guys maybe followed it on real time. We didn’t, so people kind of had the deja vu of the 1996 elections, where they went to sleep thinking that Shimon Peres is prime minister and woke up with Netanyahu. So somehow you always wake up with Netanyahu and just the person you think is going to keep replacing. So people are less optimistic now, but there is some hope that Eisenkot and his people will kind of get a sense. And people even say, “Don’t be losers! Like, do you really want to lose this? You have a majority. Why would you lose that? And maybe this kind of approach will kind of move them from where they are. I hope that if they’ll start taking over the Knesset and put on some rules, some some new laws that can kind of make them feel that they work together, it might bring some change to the minds of the people that John Ellen mentioned that needs to change their statement saying that they will not go with the standing parties.
Maytal Kowalski
It’s really interesting, really helpful. I also think you know I just I love that story because it also you know what better evidence of us of Jews being a large family than like literally what you’re describing, which is just like a massive family reunion in the streets of Israel. So that you know that that did warm my heart on this otherwise dreary Vancouver morning with kind of still some some answers up in the air. So I do appreciate that visual. Thank you. And then, Jon, I want to ask you a little bit of a different question, which is, how do you think? There’s obviously different scenarios that we’re talking about, so choose how you want to tackle this question. But how do you think, you know, if we do see some sort of change coalition, what what’s going to be the response? Like, especially from Canada, but in the international community. How do you think that international governments that have been putting so much pressure, or maybe not so much pressure, but more pressure than we’ve historically seen on Israel in the past, especially the past two years since the war in Gaza, three years since the war in Gaza? What do you think it’s going to look like as the you know, as the results come in, as the coalitions shake out and form, and as we potentially see new leadership in Israel.
Jon Allen
Okay, I’ll just say one thing about your previous question. My sister lives on Kibbutz Kfar Bloom in the north near Kiryat Shmona, and she was here visiting. And my sister is a very kind of engaged person. And every time she asked somebody who they were voting for, and she had no hesitate about asking, they were voting for Bibi, and she was it was blowing her mind. She spends every weekend at the corner, you know, protesting against him and surrounding her are these people, and she looks at them the way we look at Trump voters, and she says, “Why are you vote well, anyways?” So that’s contrast to Tel Aviv is Kiryat Shmona or yeah,
Maytal Kowalski
for sure, for sure, for sure.
Jon Allen
As to your other question, Look, I would say that you know Canada is pretty polarized. As I’m talking now, not internationally. I’m talking about the Jews of Canada. They are pretty polarized. But even the the Jews on the other side of where we are have had it with Bibi have had it with Ben Gvir and have had it with Smotrich. They know it’s harming themselves. They know it’s harming Israel, and they want them out. If they want them out, let me tell you, every Western leader except Donald Trump wants them out. They don’t want to have to deal with Bibi. They don’t want the charges that every time they criticize Israel, they’re anti-Semitic, anti-Israel, and supporting terrorism. They, you know, they’re not getting into the weeds. All they know is any government led by somebody other than Bibi, with Smotrich and Ben Gvir supporting him, would be supported by the international community, and they would give them a break. I mean, they’re not stupid. They know there’s not peace tomorrow. They know that Naftali Bennett is is pro annexation. They know that Avigdor Lieberman is worse, but they they also know that they wouldn’t have to deal with, you know, somebody that’s lied to them and and has, you know, criticized them publicly with the most vile kinds of comments. Or I’m talking about the leaders and their foreign ministers. So no question about it, they are watching and waiting, and they will give Israel a break, and they’ll see whether the violence stops. They’ll see whether there’s some movement on Gaza, whether on the Board of Peace, you know, they’ll try and do a decommissioning versus withdrawal, and maybe allow international forces in, and and allow the, you know, the technocrats that are sitting in Egypt, you know, who knows what Eisenkot and others might do if they can. I’m not sure they will, but at least there’s hope. If it’s vegan, we know we’re you know we’re back to to ground zero.
Maytal Kowalski
Yeah, yeah, okay, interesting. So look, there’s there’s so much to there’s so much to talk about. We did not touch on like the Haredi draft. We a little bit touched on the state commission of inquiry, but not hugely. There’s going to be no shortage of continued discussion and conversation coming out of here. I think this was like a really good prep for like where are we sitting right now, where things are unknown, as things shake out, we’ll know more and more. I know Jon, you’re all over the media here in Canada talking about things, so we always link to that. And I’ll link when we send this out. I’ll link to some of the interviews that I know you did prior to the election. I will also just give a plug for the incredible coverage at Haaretz. We’ll also send out that link offer that you mentioned specifically to the Canadian newsletter. But you know, it’s it’s so worth the subscription. The analysis is fantastic. Any of the things that we did not touch on or did not get further into, there is like up to the minute analysis happening over on their website. What a good time!. To To subscribe and to be able to access all of that on the English edition, that that team is doing fantastic work over there. Also, good good job to all of you, and thank you for thank you pass on my thanks to whoever it’s needed for how it’s focusing on Canada. I think that’s so cool, and we’re happy to to have worked with them in the past and hope to continue to work with them in the future, I’m so happy to get to work with and chat with both of you, incredibly intelligent gentlemen, on such a regular basis, and I really appreciate you joining me today to make some time to talk about this. So yeah, we’ll continue. Obviously, we’ll continue these conversations at J Space. Maybe we’ll see both of you again in the future to talk about these things as they continue to shake out. But for a first conversation, as we assess where we’re at, thank you so much for bringing some clarity to this topic. Any final any final thoughts? Either anything you missed or any words of encouragement that you want to that you want to bestow upon our listeners only good things though.
Ofer Matan
Jon Allen, you want to start?
Jon Allen
just what a pleasure it was to have you join us, and I hope you’ll join us again. I don’t know whether that’s conflict of interest between your job at our it’s, but it would it would be great to have you aboard again, and so thanks for doing this with us.
Ofer Matan
Sure, thank you guys. I’ll just say one thing that is semi optimistic. I just said it to my friends at lunch now. the The liberals, the Jewish liberals in Israel, are very much used to be the strong group, the the elite, and I feel that at some point the elite will not want to lose anymore. And I feel that at some point they’ll not want to lose so much that they’ll be able to go with the Palestinians and not again say no to our parties and basically voluntarily lose because they was that’s what they do. I really hope that the fact that they’re so used to be the dominant group will eventually make them say we just want to win too much and we’ll do what it takes.
Maytal Kowalski
Do the right thing. Yeah, yeah. It’s a really interesting point. That is a good point. Yeah, it. I think for especially for you know some of the some of some of the the younger folks that are paying attention, maybe for you know first or second time this time around, both in in the diaspora and in Israel, there is very much a real scenario where there are folks who only know Netanyahu or primarily only know Netanyahu as the prime minister. We forget that that there is actually a long history of strong liberal left majorities in Israel, and like, yeah, come on, guys, let’s let’s let’s let’s stop being so scared and and win this thing again. So very very very astute point, and thank you for ending us on a some little note of optimism. We’ll continue to share analysis as we go along, but thank you both right now so much for for being here today.
Ofer Matan
Thanks. Thank you. Thanks, Maytal.
This transcript is auto-generated and lightly edited. Some spelling, grammar, and syntax errors may occur.